Hi Therapist
Here is a link to a lab analysis on the major feeders available today on the SARoachman's website.
www.saroachman.co.za/Home/laboratory-analysis
You can see that the protein content in roaches is much higher that other feeders.
I also prefer roaches to crickets. Roaches is much less hassle to breed than crickets and are faster breeders too not to mention more nutritious. You can also sell off your surplus stock if they get too plentiful. I feed mine to my spiders and leopard geckos and I also supply people that have bearded dragons, marmosets, monitor lizards and some aquarium fish like oscars will take them regularly, not to mention the guys that have tenrecs.
As for housing the roaches, it's a breeze.
Get yourself a big plastic rolerbox, cut a big square hole in the lid say 30cm x 30cm and use some mosquito mesh and glue it with hot glue over the hole. It is very important for your colony to stay dry and ventilated otherwise mold will grow in your colony and it will end your colony very quickly. Get some egg cartons, you can usually buy empty cartons at your local co-op for R2 - R4 cut them to size required and stack them vertically. The reason for stacking them like this is to allow the droppings to fall to the bottom of the box and not building up in the cartons. You can now put some roaches in. As for feeding you can give them the following, I use Friskies or Whiskas dried cat food pellets as a base diet. Then you can also add extra food items like any vegetable matter to vary their diet. Just don't leave the 'wet' food in for too long as you may have a mold problem. Do not use any dairy and meat products. As for water I give them water gel or crystals. They can walk over it and eat it for water. Don't use water in a bowl because they can drown and the bodies start to rot and grow mold. If you can't get the gel or crystals you can use carrot not only is it a good food source but the moisture content in carrot is enough for them and carrot is the least likely to grow mold than any other vegetable.
If you are scared that they might climb out you can use Vaseline (clear petroleum jelly) to smear a 5 cm band around the top inside edge of the container to keep them in. I also have a Pallid roach and Madagascan hisser colony and both these are good climbers and the vaseline stops them from escaping.
You can also consider warming them during winter by sticking a heatpad on the side to up the temp. Their breeding rate can slow down very much during winter. Otherwise normal room temp in summer is more than enough and before long you will have a strong colony.
I hope this will help you decide what to do. All my insect eating pet's are healthy and happy. Just remember the healthier your feeders are, the healthier your pets are. A well balanced diet for your roaches will ensure that your spiders get all the nutrition they require. Rather give them one or two different feeding items that is healthy than a big variety of prey items that lack a good diverse diet.
As for which species is best to keep as feeders I also prefer the dubia roaches (orange spotted) they are easier for me to handle and is not as fast as the lateralis (Turkistan roaches). I keep the lateralis for the tiny pinheads they produce which is perfect for your slings.
Regards
Cronje